EGN NEWS DESK
On Christmas Eve of 2002, Laci Peterson disappeared from the Modesto, California house she shared along with her husband, Scott Peterson. The 27-year-old was eight months pregnant with the couple’s first youngster.
Four months later, the our bodies of Laci and her unborn child, who was to be named Conner, washed ashore within the San Francisco Bay. Shortly after, Scott Peterson, who stated he final noticed his spouse as he was leaving for a fishing journey at Berkeley Marina, about 90 miles west of Modesto, was arrested and charged with murdering Laci and Conner.
Scott Peterson, who was convicted of homicide in 2004 and is at the moment serving a life sentence in jail with out the opportunity of parole, has at all times maintained his innocence. In a brand new docu-series, Face to Face with Scott Peterson, he provides his first on-camera interviews since 2003. Out August 20, Face to Face additionally options conversations together with his sister-in-law Janey Peterson, former Modesto Police Department lead detective Al Brocchini and detective Jon Buehler, Scott’s former protection legal professional Lara Yeretsian, and former ABC News Producer Mike Gudgell. The sequence, directed by Shareen Anderson, who government produced A&E’s 2017 docuseries The Murder of Laci Peterson, additionally explores developments within the case for the reason that Los Angeles Innocence Project took it on in early 2024.
Here’s all the things that you must know concerning the homicide of Laci Peterson, Scott Peterson’s work with the Innocence Project, and the brand new revelations in Face to Face.
When was Scott Peterson arrested for the homicide of Laci?
Just days after Laci and Conner’s our bodies had been discovered, Scott Peterson was arrested close to a golf course in San Diego on April 18, 2003. He was charged with two counts of homicide, and pleaded not responsible to each. At the time, Peterson claimed that he arrived house from fishing to seek out the couple’s canine on a leash within the yard and no signal of Laci.
Prior to Peterson’s trial in 2004, a Fresno therapeutic massage therapist named Amber Frey claimed she had been in a relationship with him and that he had advised her he wasn’t married.
The five-month trial started in June 2004 in San Mateo County. Prosecutors alleged that Peterson had faked his spouse’s disappearance after dumping her physique within the Berkeley Marina on Christmas Eve. However, his protection attorneys argued Laci had been killed in a housebreaking.
Peterson was in the end discovered responsible by a jury and convicted of murdering Laci within the first diploma and his unborn youngster within the second diploma. The identical jury really useful that Peterson be sentenced to dying, a ruling upheld by Judge Alfred Delucchi in 2005.
What has occurred to Scott’s case since his conviction?
In 2020, the California Supreme Court overturned Peterson’s dying sentence as a result of a “sequence of clear and vital errors in jury choice.” While they upheld his homicide convictions, two months later, the state’s Supreme Court ordered a re-examination, sending the case again to the San Mateo County Superior Court, who would decide whether or not Peterson ought to obtain a brand new trial.
The California Supreme Court additionally stated that an unique juror named Richelle Nice had dedicated “prejudicial misconduct” by failing to reveal that she had been concerned with a 2000 lawsuit to acquire a restraining order in opposition to her then-boyfriend’s ex, whom she accused of stalking and harassment on the time. Nice additionally had a struggle along with her ex-boyfriend that resulted in his arrest; neither incident was disclosed to the court docket once they requested in 2005: “Have you ever been a sufferer of a criminal offense?”
In addition to sending Scott a number of letters in jail, Nice has been accused by the protection of being a “stealth juror” and trying to revenue from her place on the jury within the 2005 trial (somebody who intentionally hides their biases to make sure they’re picked for the jury panel, thus guaranteeing a responsible verdict).
In the years since, Nice granted interviews to 20/20, Dr. Oz, and E! True Hollywood Story, took half within the documentary The Murder of Laci Peterson, and co-wrote a guide with six different panelists: We, the Jury: Deciding the Scott Peterson Case. In February 2022, Nice advised the court docket that she didn’t disclose these two incidents as a result of she didn’t think about herself a criminal offense sufferer. (Nice does personally seem in Face To Face.)
In 2021, Stanislaus County District Attorney Birgit Fladager introduced that she wouldn’t retry the penalty part of the trial, which meant that Peterson can be resentenced to life in jail with out the opportunity of parole. Peterson was denied a request for a brand new trial in 2022.
How did the Los Angeles Innocence Project turn into concerned with Scott’s case?
In summer time 2023, Peterson contacted the Los Angeles Innocence Project with a request for its attorneys to analyze his case.
Speaking to the Los Angeles Times, L.A.I.P. Director Paula Mitchell, stated Peterson had “a declare of precise innocence that’s supported by newly found proof.” The nonprofit cited a mattress that was present in a burning van close to the Peterson house shortly after Laci’s disappearance as grounds for a brand new forensic examination.
“Mr. Peterson’s been ready for 20 years for police studies and audio recordings and video recordings that ought to have been supplied,” Mitchell added. “We are wanting to get our investigation underway.”
In a November 2023 assertion included within the L.A.I.P.’s discovery motions, Peterson stated: “I imagine this extra info will help in figuring out what occurred to my household and show that I’m harmless and had nothing to do with these horrible crimes that had been dedicated in opposition to my spouse and son. In 2004, I used to be wrongfully convicted of murdering my spouse, Laci, … and our unborn son, Conner.”
The L.A.I.P. will concentrate on just a few key items of recent proof, which embrace witnesses who might have seen Laci strolling her canine after Scott left to go fishing, a housebreaking throughout the road from the Petersons’ occurring across the identical time Laci disappeared (the burglars, later caught and interviewed by police, have denied having something to do with Laci’s disappearance), and a suspicious van with a blood-stained mattress that caught on hearth lower than a mile from the Petersons’ house sooner or later after Laci’s disappearance. The L.A.I.P. additionally factors to the truth that a Croton watch, probably belonging to Laci, had been offered at a pawn store just a few days after she went lacking.
What are the brand new revelations from Face To Face?
Face To Face principally excavates present info across the Laci Peterson case and speaks to events throughout the prosecution and protection. Viewers have the chance to listen to from Scott Petersonhimself, as director Shareen Anderson questions him on digicam about his affair with Amber Frey, his selection to not testify in his trial, the circumstances surrounding his 2003 arrest (Peterson was arrested 30 miles from the Mexico border with 10K in money and his brother’s ID), and what he makes of the prosecution’s argument that he killed Laci as a result of he didn’t wish to be a father or lead a home life.
“Don’t belief me. Look on the proof,” Peterson says within the sequence.
In addition to interviewing numerous neighbors who declare they witnessed Laci strolling the household canine after Scott had already left to go fishing, Face to Face builds a story that Modesto police had been too targeted on Scott – and solely Scott – throughout the preliminary investigation. In a brand new interview, present-day Scott Peterson accuses Modesto police of getting affirmation bias in opposition to him. “I simply do not get that argument [that I didn’t want to be a father], “that is simply not true.” Additionally, former neighbors and a non-public investigator employed by the Peterson household describe a scarcity of observe up from Modesto Police throughout the investigation.
Speaking on his affair with Frey, who did testify throughout the 2005 trial, Peterson causes that he withheld these particulars from police as a result of he “needed the search [for Laci] to proceed… I suppose I perceive why she tried to show it right into a relationship after the actual fact and made claims that it was one thing extra. But it merely wasn’t. That’s an enormous false impression, I believe. And I used to be completely mistaken. But I embrace the reality on that. It’s a horrible fact.”
As to why he had his brother’s ID and 1000’s in money close to the Mexico border upon being arrested, Peterson notes that he had been spending time together with his household in San Diego. Any evasive maneuvers he’d dedicated whereas driving forward of police (resulting in his arrest) had been as a result of he’d allegedly mistaken them for paparazzi. He provides that he had his brother’s ID as a way to get a reduction on the golf vary. “I suppose I used to be gonna rip-off the golf course a little bit bit.” Finally, he tells Anderson that he thought the police would understand they’d made a mistake after his arrest.
Present-day Peterson additionally wonders out loud what would have occurred if he’d let his protection group waive time on his trial as a way to current extra proof round his claimed innocence. “I might not waive time on my trial, and I look again on that now and I ponder if that was the proper choice,” Scott says. “They had the proof of my innocence… [but] It was a nightmare being caught in county jail… Now I look again on a number of the issues we realized, a number of the issues we had been nonetheless studying throughout trial, and questioned, gosh, if I had been extra prudent or affected person or no matter, perhaps issues would have been totally different.”
Face To Face additionally parses newer items of proof at the moment beneath examination by the L.A.I.P. and illustrates the probability that Laci might have confronted a housebreaking taking place throughout the road from her house in Modesto. Though the convicted burglars Steven Todd and Donald Pearce claimed that they weren’t concerned with Laci’s case (police additionally decided that they’d alibis for Christmas Eve), investigative journalists and Peterson’s sister-in-law Janey, and members of Peterson’s protection group who had been interviewed for Face To Face, level to a bigger prison community based mostly out of Modesto’s high-crime Airport district which will have been concerned in Laci’s disappearance.
These claims are bolstered by a tip from Modesto resident Tom Harshman, who says within the sequence that he known as the police twice in 2002 to report seeing a pregnant girl being “compelled into the again of a van.” The tip was not adopted up on. John Buehler, former Modesto detective, says that they obtained quite a lot of “phantom sightings” on the time and didn’t bear in mind listening to about Tom Harshman’s tip.
When requested concerning the L.A.I.P. taking over Peterson’s case, Buehler tells Face To Face that it is “not completely surprising,” whereas former detective Al Broccini calls it “bullshit… There is completely no affordable doubt he did it. [The] jury obtained it proper.”
“Anybody who says they noticed Laci strolling the canine obtained interviewed,” Broccini says. Buehler provides: “Eyewitness testimony could be very subjective. It can be very straightforward for a witness to wish to be useful, to assert later that they noticed Laci, when truly they did not, it was a mistaken id factor. Or, extra sinister, they needed to get entangled on this as a result of it was high-profile, it was within the information. We had just a few issues like that that popped up.”
“If we had the mistaken man in jail, we would wish to learn about it,” Buehler concludes.
A judge denied the vast majority of the L.A.I.P.’s DNA testing requests in May 2024. Only the duct tape discovered on Laci’s physique will likely be examined. If another person’s DNA is found, it might be sufficient to grant Petersona new trial.
